Showing posts with label new mediocre. Show all posts
Showing posts with label new mediocre. Show all posts

Monday, October 13, 2014

Bank regulators regulate based on the safety needs of the very old, and not on the risk-taking needs of the young.

On October 13 2014, in the International New York Times, Mary Williams Walsh, in “No smoke no mirrors” analyses comprehensibly the pension plan in the Netherlands.

And therein she writes that, after seeing what the financial crisis had done to the pension accounts: “Dutch young people found their voice. No matter their employment sector, they could see that their pension money was commingled with retirees’ money…[and] they realized that they and the retirees had fundamentally opposing interests. The young people were eager to keep taking investment risk, to take advantage of their long time horizon. But the retirees now wanted absolute safety, which meant investing in risk-free, cashlike assets. If all the money remained pooled, young people said, the aggressive investment returns they wanted would be diluted by the pittance that cashlike assets pay.”

Mary Williams Walsh describes precisely what should be the objection of all young people around the world to current bank regulations, but that the young, unfortunately, have not yet discovered.

The pillar of current bank regulations, is credit risk-weighted capital (equity) requirements for banks… in short more perceived credit risk more equity, less perceived risk less equity. 

And that causes banks to be able to earn much higher risk adjusted returns on assets perceived as “absolutely safe” than on assets perceived as “risky”… which leads banks to not financing the riskier future, but only to refinancing the safer past.

And given that risk-taking, not risk aversion, is what took the western world economies to become what they are, without it, they are bound to stall and fall.

And if that is not dumb short-termish regulations, which might perhaps benefit some of those baby-boomers sooner to pass away, but certainly hurt the young who risk becoming a lost generation, I do not know what is.

It would be great if the young Dutch kids also opened their eyes on this issue, and started a revolt against the banks being all castrated.

“A ship in harbor is safe, but that is not what ships are for.” John Augustus Shedd, 1850-1926

Secular stagnation, deflation, mediocre economy and all similar obnoxious creatures, are direct descendants of silly risk aversion.

Banks need to be regulated more in the interests of the advancees than in the interest of the retirees.

Friday, October 10, 2014

Yes Mme. Lagarde. It matters much where banks are going, and they’re being directed in the wrong direction.

Yes Mme. Lagarde. It matters much where banks are going, and they’re heading the wrong way.

Christine Lagarde Managing Director, International Monetary Fund in “The IMF at 70: Making the Right Choices—Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow” during The IMF/World Bank Annual Meetings, Washington, D.C. October 10, 2014, states: “It matters where we want to go in order to decide which way we go.”

Indeed it matters. And that is why I ask Christine Lagarde to use her influence to ask bank regulators: where do they want our banks to go.

I say this because in all their regulations there is not on single word about the destiny of the banks, in terms of the purpose of our banks. 

And that is of course why they have allowed themselves to impose on banks “credit-risk weighted capital requirements for banks”, which introduces a sissy silly risk aversion in the banking system and which completely distorts the allocation of bank credit to the real economy.

When Mme. Lagarde presents to us a choice between stability and fragility, that is a perfect opportunity to remind all of you that the search for stability can itself produce that stiffness, brittleness and lack of flexibility, that can lead to real monstrous fragility.

When Mme. Lagarde presents to us a choice between acceleration and stagnation that is not really a choice, since the lack of acceleration, moving forward, taking risks, will make the economy stall and fall, sooner or later.

And finally when Mme. Lagarde presents to us the choice between solidarity and seclusion, I would just note that, though there is a saying that goes “better alone than in bad company”, whenever you build a wall, you cannot be absolutely sure you end up on the right side of it.

IMF, and World Bank you have an important and urgent role to perform in holding bank regulators accountable for what they have done and are doing… please do not shy away from it.

And also never forget that secular stagnation, deflation, mediocre economy, unemployment, underemployment, managed depression and all similar obnoxious creatures, are all direct descendants of risk aversion.

“A ship in harbor is safe, but that is not what ships are for.” John Augustus Shedd, 1850-1926

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

IMF, Christine Lagarde, “the new mediocre” was ordained by risk adverse bank regulators.

Christine Lagarde speaks about “the new mediocre the state of the global economy—and the risk that the world could get stuck for some time with a ‘mediocre’ level of growth”; and of that we need a mix of bolder policies to inject a ‘new momentum that can overcome this ‘new mediocre’ that clouds the future.

The “New Mediocre” is the direct result of a growing risk adversity, most clearly illustrated by the credit-risk-weighted capital (equity) requirements for banks that for no good reason at all, distorts the allocation of bank credit, by allowing banks to earn much much higher risk-adjusted returns on equity on exposures ex ante perceived as “absolutely safe” than on exposures perceived as “risky”… since risk-taking is the oxygen of any development such risk-aversion can only lead to our economies stalling and falling, and where “mediocrity” is only a benign intermediate point.

How the IMF and others have allowed bank regulators to regulate banks without even defining the purpose of the banks, and caring exclusively about the banks and not about the allocation of bank credit to the real economy, is just incomprehensible to me.

Two times during civil society round-tables (do not ask me what civil society means) I have asked Christine Lagarde about the odious discriminatory regulations that impedes “the risky” to have fair access to bank credit, two times she has answered as she could be understanding, two times she has clearly not.



This year I will not be present at the IMF/World Bank annual meetings in Washington... (I have better things to do in her Paris :-))... but I sure hope, and pray for, that when she speaks of the “need of bolder policies”, she will understand that for that it might very well suffice with getting rid of silly and dangerous credit-risk-adverse bank regulations.

PS. Christine Lagarde, let me be even clearer still. Secular stagnation, deflation, mediocre economy, unemployment and all similar creatures, are direct descendants of silly risk aversion.

PS. Comments on IMF Global Financial Stability Report October 2014 Chapter III: Risk Taking by Banks: The role of Governance and Executive Pay