Showing posts with label Elizabeth Warren. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Elizabeth Warren. Show all posts
Monday, November 14, 2016
Senator Elizabeth Warren, in remarks given to AFL-CIO council on November 10, while trying to explain what lay behind the election of Donald Trump as president said: “Working families across this country are deeply frustrated about an economy and a government that doesn’t work for them. Exit polling on Tuesday found that 72 percent of voters believe that, quote, ‘the American economy is rigged to advantage the rich and powerful.’ The polls also made clear that the economy was the top issue on voters’ minds. Americans are angry with a federal government that works for the rich and powerful and that leaves everyone else in the dirt.”
Yes, the American economy is rigged, but at least with respect to the bank system, not exactly in the way most believe it is. I explain.
For the purposes of setting the capital requirements for banks, regulators, the Basel Committee, have decided, among others, on the following risk weights:
The sovereign (the central government and its bureaucrats) = 0%
Those rated AAA to AA (the AAArisktocracy) = 20%
Houses = 35%
The not rated, like citizen’s and SMEs = 100%
Those rated as extremely risky, like below BB-, = 150%
A lower risk weight results in having to hold less capital (equity);
That means bank can leverage their equity more;
That results in banks earning higher risk adjusted returns on equity;
That therefore means banks will lend much more to what has a low capital requirements;
In this case that means banks will lend much more than they would otherwise have done, to what is perceived, decreed or concocted as safe; and much less than the would otherwise have done to what is ex ante perceived as risky.
And so Yes! The banking system is rigged.
First and foremost, rigged in favor of the State; suggesting that when government bureaucrats use bank credit they do so much more efficiently, and generate much less risk, than if similar credit is used by the private sector/We the People.
Then rigged in favour of the banks; because being allowed to make the highest risk adjusted returns on equity on what is perceived as safe, must be a dream come true for all those bankers, described by Mark Twain, as wanting to lend you the umbrella when the sun was out, and wanting it back as soon it looked it could rain
Rigged in favor of the AAArisktocracy; by believing that a few human fallible credit rating agencies will always get it right, and that credit ratings, based on an ex ante very low risk perception, guarantees a very low ex post risk.
Rigged in favour of those buying houses, for instance basements were unemployed youth can live with their parents.
It is rigged against We the (risky) People
It is rigged against SMEs and entrepreneurs; negating the “risky” credit opportunities, it is a major driver of inequality.
It is foremost rigged against the young; because it makes banks refinance more their parents “safer” past and present, than their “riskier” future.
And all that risk aversion... in the Home of the Brave. America would never ever have become what it is, with this senseless bank regulation. Risk-taking is the oxygen of all development.
God make us daring!
Wednesday, April 1, 2015
An indebted unemployed student’s story:
An indebted unemployed student: "At last I thought I had a reasonably good paying job that would make me be able to repay my student debt, and earn me something on top of that, for all the time and efforts I had invested in my studies. But, that was not to be, because the owner of the SME who was offering me the job, had his credit application denied by the local bank that had the most intimate knowledge of his business and plans. Much saddened, even despaired, I asked the employer I had counted on… How come?”
SME owner: “The banker told me that if he gave me the loan then, because I was officially perceived as risky from a credit risk point of view, regulators required him to hold much more equity than if he lent that money to an AA rated corporation or invested it in treasury bills. And, unfortunately, he did not have that equity.”
Indebted unemployed student: “What? In the home of the brave, banks are required to hold more equity against loans to the supposedly risky than against loans to the supposedly safe?”
SME owner: “Yes, ever since the US signed up on the principles of the Basel Accord back in 1988, and especially after the approval of Basel II in 2004, that is how it is. Sorry my dear unemployed student loan debtor, there’s nothing I can do about it! I am just as sad and hurt.”
Indebted unemployed student: “But why would the regulators do a thing like that?”
SME owner: “Beats me. As far as I know all real big bank crises have never ever resulted from excessive loans to “risky” SMEs and entrepreneurs like me, these have always resulted from excessive bank exposures to what banks, and regulators, believed to be absolutely safe, but turn out not to be.”
Indebted unemployed student: “But that’s plain crazy!”
SME owner: “Indeed, it is an odious discrimination, and by killing opportunities it promotes inequality. But, no one dares to question the regulators, especially when it has become so fashionable to question bankers… or perhaps the regulators are all just statists and love the idea that banks should foremost lend money to government bureaucracy, as well as to their intimate friends of the AAArisktocracy they usually see in Davos.”
This fictitious but sadly too real story, is sent upon request to Rep Elijah Cummings and Senator Elizabeth Warren
PS. I have always believed students should be given access to student debt as if they were AAA rated, because although they might not have an AAA credit rating, they sure have an AAA rated purpose. That said, much much more important than their debts, are their possibilities of future jobs.
Tuesday, December 23, 2014
Let the market rule on risky trades
Let the market rule on risky trades
Harold Meyerson referred in his Dec. 18 op-ed column, "Warren's friends on the right," to Democratic senators joining Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) in voting against "allowing publicly insured banks to trade risky derivatives."
How do these senators know that these derivatives are more risky than AAA-rated securities collateralized by subprime mortgages or loans to "infallible sovereigns" such as Greece?
The economic crisis in the Western world can be traced to excessive bank lending - to borrowers regulators considered absolutely safe, against minimum capital, meaning minimum equity.
The home of the brave needs to beware of too much dangerous nannying because nannying is not what made it great.
The Washington Post
Here other of my letters in the Washington Post on this issue:
September 6, 2007: Factors in the Financial Storm
June 20, 2008: An Aspect of the Bubble
December 27, 2009: Another 'worst': Faulty bank regulation
September 6, 2007: Factors in the Financial Storm
June 20, 2008: An Aspect of the Bubble
December 27, 2009: Another 'worst': Faulty bank regulation
January 6, 2012: Handcuffed by a triple-A rating
May 1, 2013: An American approach to banking
November 11, 2015: Reverse-mortgaging the future
August 9, 2016: Banks, regulators and risk
April 16, 2017: When banks play it too safe
May 1, 2013: An American approach to banking
November 11, 2015: Reverse-mortgaging the future
August 9, 2016: Banks, regulators and risk
April 16, 2017: When banks play it too safe
Let the market rule on risky trades
Let the market rule on risky trades
Harold Meyerson referred in his Dec. 18 op-ed column, "Warren's friends on the right," to Democratic senators joining Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) in voting against "allowing publicly insured banks to trade risky derivatives."
How do these senators know that these derivatives are more risky than AAA-rated securities collateralized by subprime mortgages or loans to "infallible sovereigns" such as Greece?
The economic crisis in the Western world can be traced to excessive bank lending - to borrowers regulators considered absolutely safe, against minimum capital, meaning minimum equity.
The home of the brave needs to beware of too much dangerous nannying because nannying is not what made it great.
The Washington Post
Here other of my letters in the Washington Post on this issue:
September 6, 2007: Factors in the Financial Storm
June 20, 2008: An Aspect of the Bubble
December 27, 2009: Another 'worst': Faulty bank regulation
September 6, 2007: Factors in the Financial Storm
June 20, 2008: An Aspect of the Bubble
December 27, 2009: Another 'worst': Faulty bank regulation
January 6, 2012: Handcuffed by a triple-A rating
May 1, 2013: An American approach to banking
November 11, 2015: Reverse-mortgaging the future
August 9, 2016: Banks, regulators and risk
April 16, 2017: When banks play it too safe
May 1, 2013: An American approach to banking
November 11, 2015: Reverse-mortgaging the future
August 9, 2016: Banks, regulators and risk
April 16, 2017: When banks play it too safe
Friday, September 7, 2012
And, who is Elizabeth Warren to speak about “The system is rigged”?
If there is something that you can really accuse the financial system of being rigged by, that are the capital requirements for banks based on perceived risks. These requirements favor immensely those already being favored by the markets, namely those borrowers perceived as “The Infallible”, and thereby discriminate immensely against those already being discriminated against by the markets, namely those borrowers perceived as “The Risky”, like small businesses and entrepreneurs.
And that odious discrimination, constitutes a regulatory wedge which only increases the existing the inequalities and reduce the opportunities, as the “The Infallible” are most often the haves, and, the “The Risky”, the not haves.
And since Elizabeth Warren, having been involved with regulations for such a long time, has not uttered a word against that regulatory discrimination, I am not sure what moral right she has to speak out about “The system is rigged”?
What nonsense is believing in a "level playing field", and then not speaking out against colleagues and regulations un-leveling it? What has regulatory discrimination against those perceived as "risky" to do with "giving everyone a fair shot"? What has this extreme regulatory risk-adverseness to do with the need to "restore the values that built the nation"? Is not just betting on The Infallible "betting against the American people"?
What nonsense is believing in a "level playing field", and then not speaking out against colleagues and regulations un-leveling it? What has regulatory discrimination against those perceived as "risky" to do with "giving everyone a fair shot"? What has this extreme regulatory risk-adverseness to do with the need to "restore the values that built the nation"? Is not just betting on The Infallible "betting against the American people"?
She said in her recent Democratic Convention speech: “I talk to small business owners all across Massachusetts. Not one of them—not one—made big bucks from the risky Wall Street bets that brought down our economy.” And I must say: “No, Elizabeth Warren, of course they did not, they were too busy having to pay all that extra interest rates to the banks that the bank regulations caused.”
She said in her recent Democratic Convention speech: “We turned adversity into progress because that's what we do” And I must say: “No, Elizabeth Warren, you did not! You were among those many regulators who want to turn progress into risk-adversity! And this, amazingly, in the land of the brave!”
But, let me be absolutely clear, I could use exactly the same arguments against all those on the other side of the political spectrum who extol the benefits of a free market, but who also keep absolute silence about this dirty regulatory intervention and distortion of the market. And so they should shut up too!
Does this mean I do not support the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau? Of course I support it! Only that I believe that one of that Bureau´s first responsibilities, is to see that those perceived as “risky”, are not also discriminated against by the regulators.
Albert Einstein dixit: “No problem can be solved from the same level of consciousness that created it”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

